Saturday, January 17, 2009

We Get it CBC, There's a Deficit Coming

I don't know about anyone else, but I'm getting really tired of CBC's constant stories about how the upcoming budget is going to run a deficit. My reaction is generally something along the lines of "no shit, Sherlock." Everyone and her dog knew that a deficit was coming, except for the Conservatives well before the failed fiscal update that triggered a constitutional crisis. CBC seems determined to try to scare people with horrible economy stories. It's very reminiscent of Fox News and it's fear factory approach to reporting.

My message to CBC: give it a rest. We know the economy is bad, and we know a deficit is coming. You need to stop telling us to be afraid, to be very afraid, and start treating the Canadian public like a group of rational adults (no matter that we may not behave like it sometimes).

On a positive note, the window for George Bush to pre-emptively pardon his torture-cronies is closing quickly. He's only got eighty-two hours left as Preident.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 3

Thursday, January 15, 2009

A Momentous Time

As we approach the end of the reign of George Bush II, it becomes evident, to all but the most-close-eyed conservatives the hell to which we've been carried in Bush's hand-basket.

Human disasters are unfolding across the world. In Afghanistan and Iraq, the imperial west is brutally occupying, whether to extract oil or to protect pipeline routes. In Gaza the Palestinians are being slaughtered for political gain, in an appallingly crass, hubristic and hypocritical display. The genocide in Darfur continues to unfold, and American ally states from Lebanon to Pakistan to Georgia have been declaring states of emergency and clamping down on democratic opposition.

The great glory of modern capitalism, our globalized economy, is coming apart at the seams as economies across the world melt down, throwing workers out on the street, and bringing new protestations of Keynesian faith, despite the fact that the supposedly socialistic policy of bailouts simply enriches those already bloated with ill-gotten wealth. Bush and his wild-eyed acolytes of laissez-faire and the unfettered free market have proven to be unspeakable failures at managing the economy, as the ideological bankruptcy of their economic ideologies is proven to be matched only by its moral bankruptcy as in engages in one last orgy of upward redistribution of wealth. Executives get golden parachutes and workers get the soup kitchen line.

As laid out by the late, great, and incomparable Molly Ivins and Lou Dubose in their book Bill of Wrongs, the Bush regime has encouraged an all out assault on the principles of constitutional government in the United States, and this has had knock-on effects across the world. Canada puts in place Gitmo North and imprisons four men for eight years without charge, the opportunity to face their accusers or to know the evidence against them. Great Britain collapses into an agonized security state in which the average citizen of London is recorded on camera three hundred times every day, which would make Big Brother jealous. States in eastern Europe hold and torture men who have been kidnapped by the American government, in a practice called, with a chilling sterility, extraordinary rendition. American puppet regimes in the Middle East torture others, including Maher Arar who was confirmed to have committed no crime.

Bush and his flunkies have radically undermined the emergence of an international legal order, attempting to scuttle the International Criminal Court after securing major concessions. They have sabotaged attempts to save our climate from radical and disastrous change by recanting America's signature on the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. They have undermined the Geneva Conventions on the Law of War by creating the status of illegal enemy combatant that has no basis in law and is simply an excuse to hold the racialized other forever in a legal black hole.

This is but a brief and incomplete catalogue of the worst excesses, and high crimes, of George Bush, called Dubya. But not all is dark.

In the election on Nov. 4, 2008 Americans spoke resoundingly of a desire for change. While they likely will get only cosmetic change out of Barack Obama, Americans were mobilized and involved in politics in a way not seen since the election of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. Americans have been jolted out of political apathy, and it is to be hoped that their awakening will be transmitted to the slumbering populations of the rest of the industrialized world.

In Latin America a radical transformation of both economics and politics is gaining steam. A truly democratic and socialist movement has arisen, and is demanding justice and equality for their people, and an end to the domination of their states by their wealthy paleo-colonialist elites and foreign corporations. The people of Venezuela resisted an American-sponsored coup in 2002 that was eerily reminiscent of the coups in the southern cone during the 1970s. The workers and the indigenous populations have reclaimed control of their countries in Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador. Centre-leftists have been elected by wide margins in Brazil, Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and Paraguay. South America faces a revolutionary moment, and it provides a template that can be followed across the South.

As the economy melts down, that defining revolutionary moment spreads into the industrialized economies. It is a self-evident failure of capitalism. Socialists must be ready with alternatives to present, or we will lose this moment, as we lost the moment of the Great Depression.

The last days of George W. Bush are a time for celebration, as the global tyrant leaves the scene. But we can't stop at celebration. We must push for a true revolutionary moment, to bring democratic socialism to all the people of the world.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 6

Monday, January 12, 2009

Israeli War Crimes Confirmed in Gaza

Wide confirmation (see e.g. here) is beginning to come in that Israel has used, and is continuing to use white phosphorous (WP) against the civilian population of Gaza. Human Rights Watch observers in southern Israel (they are barred by Israeli forces from entering Gaza), saw shells fired over a Gazan refugee camp that left trails characteristic of WP shells, and exploded in a manner consistent with WP, which produces unique looking explosions.

WP is a weapon banned from use in civilian areas by the 1980 Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, Protocol III. Wikipedia lists the following as effects on humans of exposure to WP:
Effects of Exposure to WP Weapons

Incandescent particles of WP cast off by a WP weapon's initial explosion can produce extensive, deep (second and third degree) burns. Phosphorus burns carry a greater risk of mortality than other forms of burns due to the absorption of phosphorus into the body through the burned area, resulting in liver, heart and kidney damage, and in some cases multi-organ failure. These weapons are particularly dangerous to exposed people because white phosphorus continues to burn unless deprived of oxygen or until completely consumed. In some cases burns are limited to exposed areas of skin because the smaller WP particles do not burn completely through personal clothing before being consumed...

Exposure and Inhalation of Smoke

Burning WP produces a hot, dense white smoke. Most forms of smoke are not hazardous in the kinds of concentrations produced by a battlefield smoke shell. Exposure to heavy smoke concentrations of any kind for an extended period (particularly if near the source of emission) does have the potential to cause illness and even death.

WP smoke irritates the eyes and nose in moderate concentrations. With intense exposures, a very explosive cough may occur. However, no recorded casualties from the effects of WP smoke alone have occurred in combat operations, and to date there are no confirmed deaths resulting from exposure to phosphorus smoke...
As you can see, this is a worse weapon than napalm in terms of damage to the human body. Once you are hit with it, you can't get it off. It literally burns its way into the skin. The fact that it reacts with oxygen means that it cannot be put out with water, and trying to do so only makes the problem worse.

WP was used against the people of Fallujah by American occupation forces in Iraq during the 2004 massacre. That is one of the best documented uses of WP against a densely concentrated area of civilians. The USA violated the laws of war in Fallujah, and Israel is doing so now, using WP in a banned capacity. This is at least as terrorist as anything Hamas has done, including suicide bombings. This is a weapon used without fear of consequences designed to kill civilians and terrorize them into behaving in the desired manner. This is terrorism.

Israel claims to want peace, but with every action it takes, it undermines the chance for that peace, driving home the message to the Palestinians that they are not to be allowed to live in peace themselves. Israel's version of peace requires that the Palestinians be subjucated, racialized and imprisoned in an enormous open-air concentration camp called Gaza, in which they will be left to starve in the dark. If Israel is unwilling to live in true peace, how can it expects the colonized and brutalized people of the occupied territories to be willing to do the same?

There can be no peace without justice. Justice for Palestine!

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 8

[Update] White phosphorus shelling has been confirmed in the Israeli destruction of a United Nations compound in Gaza.

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Israel, Gaza, Hamas and a Look at Causes

I think it's time I wrote something a bit more fleshed out about the situation of the Palestinians in Gaza. At the beginning, I should make my view of the entire Israeli-Palestinian history clear. I view it as an essentially colonialist enterprise after the point at which Zionist philosophy enters the picture. I don't pretend to a balanced point of view, or to neutrality. I am anti-imperialist and anti-colonialist, and this means that I am pro-Palestinian. I should also state that I think Israel is here to stay, and the people of Israel should have a state within their pre-1967 borders. There won't be any functional reversal of the expulsion of Palestinians in 1948, and Israel isn't going anywhere. I don't go to the extremes of some who believe that there is an organized campaign of ethnic cleansing against the Palestinians, but I do believe that Israel's policies toward the Palestinians are not functionally different than those of the white government of Apartheid South Africa. I also don't believe that all Israeli citizens, or all of Israel's Jewish population, support the actions of their government with regard to the Palestinians. There is a peace movement within Israel with both Jewish and Arab members, and I wish them the very best with their work.

To find the beginning of the current fighting in Gaza is an exercise in nearly infinite chicken-and-egg reasoning. Causes and effects can be traced back before the founding of Israel, and I don't have the time or the inclination to go into that. To find the immediate cause, I look to the ceasefire deal negotiated indirectly about seven months ago between Israel and Hamas, the legally elected governing party of the Palestinians. In this deal, there were a couple of essential points for each side. Essentially, Israel wanted an end to rockets into the south of Israel. Essentially Hamas wanted an end to bombings/missile strikes, and the opening of the borders of the Gaza Strip. Neither side seemed to have been making unrealistic demands.

Beginning in early November of 2008, Israel killed eleven Hamas personnel (militants or security personnel depending on who you ask) over eleven days, leading Hamas to fire rockets into Israel once again. This is an undisputed fact, as reported by the International Herald Tribune. The Israeli response to these rockets was to tighten the economic blockade of Gaza, which had never really been lifted, despite the deal, essentially placing Gaza under siege and cutting supplies of food and fuel. These events set off a spiral of violence that, over about two months, developed into the brutalization now taking place in Gaza.

In the light of those facts, it is clear that the cease-fire was never properly implemented, as Israel did not fulfil it's side of the bargain. This means that it is Israeli bad-faith negotiation that is the intermediate cause of the current violence, and Israeli breaches of other terms of the cease fire that is the immediate cause. Increased rocketing by Hamas was certainly unhelpful, and likely provoked a more extreme Israeli response, but it is clear that Israel expected complete compliance with the terms of the cease fire deal from Hamas without delivering the same itself.

That is an unfortunate pattern in Israeli dealings with the Palestinians, that has been repeated time and again. As an example, the Oslo Accords agreed to a right of passage between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, but this was repeatedly infringed upon by Israel. The history of bad faith negotiation on the part of the Israelis makes it hard to believe that they will keep any new agreement that is reached to end this current attack on Gaza.

Israel's approach to Gaza in particular has been highly unethical and immoral. Beyond the bad faith negotiations, Israel has inflicted collective punishment on the people of Gaza both in the form of the blockade and in the form of bombing civilians. It has violated principles of international law protecting civilians. A civilian population does not lose its protected status at international law because an army's enemies are hiding amongst them, despite the claims of Israel, and of every other modern occupier from the United States in Iraq, Canada in Afghanistan, Russia in Chechnya and so forth. This is exemplified by the bombing yesterday of a United Nations school that was clearly marked as such, killing at least 39 people. Israel claimed that mortar shells were fired from that location, as if that excused knowingly killing civilians.

As Devin Johnston says, the only way to peace is for one side to let bumps in the road to peace pass, and not use them as an excuse for renewing or escalating the cycle of violence. As I see it, it must be Israel that does this. Israel is the occupier, and it faces no existential threat from the Palestinians. Israel has the capacity to destroy all society in the occupied territories. The Palestinians have no such capacity with regard to Israel. Despite the number of rockets fired into Israel in December (approximately 3,000) only five Israelis were killed. Contrast that with the first week of the Israeli bombing of Gaza in which 400+ people died, and that fact comes into focus. However, this is only one necessary condition. Israel must tear down the Apartheid walls it has built, and withdraw settlements from the West Bank. Israel is going to have to return East Jerusalem. Without these things, it is difficult to see how the Palestinians can consent to an agreement.

As an aside before I wrap up, Israel demands as a precondition of peace that Hamas recognize the right of Israel to exist. No state has the right to exist at international law. Israel is demanding something that no other state has, or can have at international law. What Israel can legitimately demand is that Hamas recognize the right of the people of Israel to live in peace - but Israel must recognize the same for the people of Palestine.

Ultimately, you cannot fight for peace. Peace must come through dialogue, and negotiation. Peace will not come from the barrel of a tank cannon or the explosion of a Quassam rocket. Peace will come when both sides are willing to make concessions, and to realize that each will have to give up some of what it wants in order to have peace. I believe it is possible and necessary. As John Lennon put it:

Imagine there's no countries
It isn't hard to do
Nothing to kill or die for
And no religion too
Imagine all the people
Living life in peace...

You may say I'm a dreamer
But I'm not the only one
I hope someday you'll join us
And the world will be as one

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 12

EI and Stimulus

On Wednesday, the Liberals decided to announce that they want the Harper government to improve EI as part of the budget in order to obtain their support. That's all well and good, but coming from the Liberals, it seems like a rather last minute trip along the road to Damascus. Liberals are the same party that effectively gutted EI in the 1990s to finance their deficit reduction. They stole billions from Canadian workers, and used it to pay down the debt and deficit. I'm glad they've finally seen the light, but it seems rather late.

Improving EI is an excellent way to stimulate the economy, because it keeps families who have lost jobs able to buy their essentials, and pay their bills, which flows money back into the economy. It's also the right thing to do, because these workers have been paying EI premiums for years, and deserve the security it brings, so that losing one's job does not mean an instantaneous disaster. Workers have given their sweat, tears and (far too often) their blood, for this county. It's time for the country to give back to them.

In their Alterative Budget, the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives called for the injection of $3.4 billion into the EI programme, to increase benefits to 60% of insurable income, and coverage to fifty weeks. EI is the very definition of counter-cyclical spending, since it spends money when the economy is bad, and saves money when the economy is doing well (at least it saves when the feds don't steal its surplus).

Canadian workers deserve the support of their government, and enriching EI is a good way to give that support. If the Liberals want to get on the pro-worker train, the more the merrier. But they're going to have to prove that they have earned their seats.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 12

Tuesday, January 06, 2009

Tax Cuts Aren't Stimulus

The Finance Minister is an idiot. I'm going to put that out there now. He's also a liar and a crook, but that's a different story. This one is about how Jim Flaherty thinks that tax cuts are a form of counter-cyclical stimulus. He is talking about including tax cuts in the federal budget due at the end of January.

I'm sorry, this is a moronic move. The kind of tax cuts that Conservatives like are narrowly focused on the capitalist class, and emphasize trickle-down voodoo economics. Supply-side tax cuts are unequivocally not what we need in this economic climate. I don't think we generally ever need them, but that is, again, something for another entry, but we especially don't need them when our economy is staring massive over-production in the face. Providing tax cuts intended to increase capital investment is an inappropriate move in the current economic environment. If the Conservatives are bound and determined to have tax cuts in the budget, then cut marginal taxes for the lowest tax bracket, and maybe raise the basic personal exemption. This is the kind of tax measure that might be helpful. Those who would benefit from the measure are the people who live from paycheque to paycheque, and spend every cent they get. This money goes right back into the economy, and stimulates demand, easing the crisis of overproduction, without sacrificing jobs.

But I don't think tax cuts are the way to go right now. Tax cuts aren't a good method of counter-cyclical stimulation of the economy. Counter-cyclical stimulation, in the typical Keynesian mode, requires that the stimulation be capable of easing off when the economy no longer requires stimulation. Tax cuts cause a major problem in this regard, because in the current political climate it is very difficult to raise taxes, when the economy no longer needs the stimulation. We have seen a practical example of this in Canada. In the last election, Stephane Dion mused about the possibility of raising the GST back to 7%, and the howling across the country was deafening.

The best way to stimulate the economy is infrastructure spending. Infrastructure spending has five aspects that make it good for counter-cyclical stimulation:
  1. It is capable of getting to work quickly, since most cities and counties have some kind of infrastructure project just waiting for funding to go into effect. An example is the Transit City proposal in the City of Toronto, envisioning many more streetcar lines to greatly increase the available transportation in the city.
  2. It puts people to work, both in the immediate construction industry and in the feed-in system, creating a ripple effect across the economy. By putting people to work, more money is earned, and that helps to ease the overproduction crisis.
  3. It stimulates demand for products manufactured in Canada, helping to keep well-paid manufacturing jobs in Canada.
  4. Building infrastructure leaves something that will be useful for decades. A new subway line can be used for a hundred years or more (see London and New York), a new streetcar line for decades. Building infrastructure is a part of long-term economic planning.
  5. It can be easily eased off when the economy recovers.
Obviously, infrastructure spending can't be the whole deal, but it is a far better way than idiotic Conservative tax cuts that will be secreted in bank accounts, and not put to work on products made in Canada. We need real stimulus in this budget.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 14

Sunday, January 04, 2009

Back to Blogging

Hi everyone. This is just a quick note to apologize for the long absence from the blog. When I was home over the holidays I didn't blog due to a combination of only sporadic Internet access and not having the inclination. But I'll be getting back to it now.

I also want to take a moment to unequivocally condemn the bombardment and now invasion of the Gaza Strip by Israel. Israel is exacting vastly disproportionate revenge through collective punishment. It claims that this most recent brutalization of the Palestinians is a necessary response to the rockets launched from Gaza over the last eight years, some thousands of them. Sure, when you give the number of rockets, it sounds bad, but then think about the number of deaths. From eight years from 2000 to 2008, rockets fired from Gaza killed 21 Israelis. In the eight days this offensive has lasted, more than 440 Palestinians have been killed. In the month of December, rockets killed four Israelis. This means that in December, Israel killed 110 Palestinians (including at least 100 people with no connection to Hamas) for every Israeli killed. How that is defensible to anyone is beyond my understanding. Israel is engaging in an Orwellian effort to brutalize the people of Palestine into turning against Hamas. They tried that in Lebanon in 2006 vis-a-vis Hezbollah. Anyone want to remind me how that turned out? If Israel wants peace, they must also create the conditions for Palestinians to live in peace, and this includes withdrawing from occupied territories, tearing down the apartheid wall and lifting the seige of Gaza.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 16

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Iggy to be Liberal Leader

Democracy in the Liberal Party is dead today. Bob Rae has dropped out, and Iggy will be crowned interim leader, to become permanent leader in May. He has not had to face a single vote from the membership of the Liberal Party of Canada.

Iggy is a right-winger, who believes that the invasion of Iraq was a good idea, and that torture can be justified. I have great qualms about the coalition going forward with him as leader. He is a clone of King Stephen on a lot of things, even down to the condescending attitude. The Liberals will be led by the Man Who Would Be Philosopher King. The man who sees the coalition not as a way to represent the will of 62% of Canadians but rather as a tool to extract concessions from the Conservatives.

I don't know if the coalition can go with Iggy the Hawk in charge of the Liberals.

Of course, Iggy leading the Liberal Party is in the partisan best interests of the NDP. He will draw CPC-LPC swing voters, and drive LPC-NDP swing voters to the NDP. This may help the NDP gain seats in Atlantic Canada and in Ontario. At the same time, the LPC can gain seats from the CPC in Ontario and maybe from the BQ in Quebec. It may be enough to knock King Stephen off his throne in the Dictatorial Republic of Canada.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 41

Friday, December 05, 2008

National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women

On December 6, 1989 Marc Lepine entered L'Ecole Polytechnique in Montreal and killed Genevieve Bergeron, Helen Colgan, Nathalie Croteau, Barbara Daigneault, Anne-Marie Edward, Maud Haviernick, Maryse Laganiere, Anne-Marie Lemay, Sonia Pelletier, Michele Richard, Annie St-Arneault, Annie Turcotte and Barbara Klucznik-Widajewicz. This event has become known as the Montreal Massacre.

Since 1991 we have marked the anniversary of this tragedy with the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women. On this above all days we remember all women who have been killed and harmed by men. The fourteen killed at L'Ecole Polytechnique were killed because they were women, and because Lepine had a violent hatred of feminists.

We must stand against all violence against women, and take every possible action to ensure that no woman is killed by her partner or because she is a woman. We must also act to ensure that women are equal in all ways to men.

May the fourteen and all other women killed by men rest in peace.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 46

Thursday, December 04, 2008

Pro-Coalition Rally in Halifax

There was a great pro-coalition rally in Halifax today at Maritime Hall.

Here are some of the pictures:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

My sign for the rally:

Photobucket

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 47

The Governor General Has Sabotaged Parliamentary Democracy

The Governor General has allowed the Prime Minister to prorogue Parliament just a few weeks after the session began, without anything passing the House and simply to allow the government to escape the loss of the confidence. The Governor General has fundamentally sabotaged the nature of parliamentary democracy by allowing Harper to govern without Parliament. This is contrary to the basic nature of representative parliamentary democracy.

The government must be responsible to the Parliament, and must be able to sustain the confidence of Parliament. The Governor General by granting prorogation has allowed Harper to abrogate this principle, and ought to be ashamed of herself. She has allowed a lying, mendacious, cowardly and bullying Prime Minister to display contempt for Parliament and for the institution of the Constitution of Canada. She ought to be ashamed of herself.

This is absolutely unprecedented in Canada. The Governor General has effectively allowed Harper to do what he wants because he doesn't like what Parliament is up to. The institution of the Governor General has betrayed Canada. The Governor General has endorse a campaign of lies by the Prime Minister that is unprecedented in Canada. She has impeached the honour of her office by endorsing it. That she would allow Harper to display such craven cowardice as to suspend Parliament to avoid the loss of confidence is absolutely shameful.

No government without Parliament! Constitution now!

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 47

Tenterhooks

I can hardly take it. Harper's been in with the Governor-General for an hour now, and still nothing.

Harper has stirred up the greatest political and economic crisis in decades, and is deliberately fanning the flames of a national unity debate to save his own job. He has done this with LIES.

I'll have more once we find out if Harper got an answer from the G-G.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 47

Wednesday, December 03, 2008

Prop 8, The Musical

This, this is brilliant.



Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 48

Will He or Won't He

The question now is whether Harper will prorogue Parliament to avoid an official loss of the confidence of the House. I really hope he doesn't, both because I want to see the coalition come to pass and because if he does it will be a huge blow to parliamentary democracy.

The fundamental principle of parliamentary democracy is that the government remains in office so long as it enjoys the confidence of the Parliament, and in Canada that means the House of Commons. The corollary of this principle is that the executive branch governs with the Parliament, so that if the confidence is lost, the Parliament may signal that that is so, and the government leaves office. If the Governor-General grants Harper a prorogation, the executive will functionally be governing without Parliament, in violation of the basic principles of Parliamentary democracy.

Prorogation, for those that don't know, ends the session of the Parliament, until it is recalled for a new session with a new Speech from the Throne. This kills all bills on the order paper and sends MPs back to their constituencies. Essentially, the legislative branch of government is dismissed, while the executive continues to govern. There is no precedent in Canada for a prorogation so early in a first session of a Parliament, and no precedent for a prorogation before anything other than the motion approving the Speech from the Throne has passed the House.

If Harper obtains a prorogation from the Governor General, it will be a blatant admission that the government no longer enjoys the confidence of the House, and will represent a brazen abuse of the Prime Minister's power to advise the Governor-General on the convention and dismissal of Parliament. If there is a prorogation, it will be a clear statement that Harper's government is illegitimate, and governing in an anti-democratic and anti-constitutional manner.

So the question now is, as I posed above, will he or won't he. In the House today, Harper said that his government would take all legal means to avoid defeat (and some of his supporters in Alberta are committing sedition by saying they will take up arms if he falls). I take this to mean that he is threatening the coalition with a prorogation. I still don't know if he would do it though, given how massively illegitimate it would render his government.

I want to hear from everyone who reads this, do you think he will or won't? I'm interested in what you think regardless of where you fall on the political spectrum.

By the way, there are going to be rallies across the country on Thursday in support of the coalition for change. I'll be out in Halifax. You can find information on the rallies, including whether there is one in your neck of the woods at http://www.makeparliamentwork.com/.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 48

Tuesday, December 02, 2008

Coalition Bloggers

There is a growing network of bloggers out there who are supporting the Liberal-NDP coalition. I'm happy to be one of them.

Ordinarily, I have my qualms about working with the Liberals. They tend to govern as technocratic, corporatist and coldly capitalistic. Their history in government is distressingly similar on fiscal issues to that of the Conservative Party. The difference comes on social issues. While the Liberals may have to be dragged kicking and screaming to modern positions on issues like equal marriage and a woman's right to choose, at least once they get put in the right place on those issues they have a tendency to stay there. Whether this is reflective of the Liberal Party's congenital institutional inertia or not is hard to say, but at least it happens. The Conservatives may be temporarily dragged to a semi-modern position (i.e. equal marriage is a closed issue), but they have a tendency to back-track when we aren't looking, for example bill C-484, the attempt to bestow rights on the collection of cells known as as a foetus.

I find myself in a mirror image position to that of Jason Cherniak. He is a fiscal conservative, and self-identified blue Liberal. Yet he endorses the coalition because the alternative is Stephen Harper. I find myself thinking the same way. I am a socialist, and on the left of the NDP. But I support this coalition, because a) it gets us the most left-wing government we've had in a very long time, and b) because it isn't Stephen Harper.

Harper has done incalculable damage to the institutions of Canadian government, from turning standing committees of the House of Commons into three-ring circuses, to abusing the requirement of confidence to instituting sweeping policy changes without debate in the House through orders in council and the discretion of ministers of the Crown. If nothing else, the Liberals have a respect for the institutions of this country that the Conservatives lack. The NDP does as well. We (and I) may want to see the Senate abolished, as an example, but we believe that while it is in existence it has important work to do. We believe that the courts of this country should not be packed with partisan judges picked for their ideology. We believe that government can be a force for good.

If people from blue Liberals to socialists can support this deal, I believe that this is an indication that it will have wide support in Canada, Conservative hysterics and freeping of call-in shows and Internet forums notwithstanding. To show my support, I've added the badge that now appears at the top of the right hand column of my blog. Eventually, there will also be a website (coalitionbloggers.ca). If you want to contribute to the discussion about what that site should do or be, feel free to post comments either here, or on Dipper Chick. If you are a blogger supportive of the coalition, I urge you to add the badge to your blog as well. The code can be found at the link above.

We have to remember that what the coalition is doing is legal and constitutional, but more over it is both ethical and moral. We are faced by a regressive Conservative government instituting policy direct from the Reform Party platform of the mid-1990s, none of which was mentioned in the election campaign. The CPC may have withdrawn their attempts to eliminate public electoral funding and the right to strike of public sector workers, but they are still trying to legislate away the gains of a decade and a half for women employed in the public service, and if we let them off the hook this time, you can bet that those other measures will be back.

Now is not the time for half-measures. We must be resolute, and we must be strong. Now is manifestly the time for actions, and a better way forward is in our grasp. If we don't take it now, it will recede out of reach for years. Write to your MP and the Governor General (info@gg.ca). Let them know that you support the coalition. Remember the immortal words of Tommy Douglas: "courage, my friends. 'Tis not too late to make a better world." And never let anyone tell you it can't be done.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 49

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Coalition Deal Completed

The NDP and Liberals have reached a deal to form a coalition government, according to the CBC. According to this deal, the NDP will get 25% of the Cabinet seats, and will not get to name either the Deputy Prime Minister or the Finance Minister.

This is a good thing. I was hoping for a few more Cabinet seats (more like 33%), but this is good. This gives the chance to put in place a government working in the interests of Canadians unlike the hopelessly partisan and bully-boy Conservatives. Given the opportunity, this new government will bring in fiscal stimulus, and avoid the harms of a couple more years of Harper.

I'm not going to be focusing on the blatant illegalities of the taping of the NDP caucus meeting by the Conservatives. It is a sideshow they are setting up to try to distract from their completely flop of a fiscal update. I won't be distracted, and I urge the entire progressive community online not to get caught up in it either.

I'll have more information on the coalition deal as it emerges.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 51

Canada Has Our Very Own Watergate

Buried in a CBC News story about how the Conservatives are moving up the date of the budget, we find this:

The Conservatives, meanwhile, have released details of an NDP caucus meeting they say was held in the form of a conference call on Saturday.

The Tories say they released a portion of the transcript on Sunday because it shows the NDP was working very closely with the Bloc long before last Thursday's economic update to replace the government.

"Let's just say we have strategies," NDP Leader Jack Layton said during the call. "This whole thing would not have happened if the moves hadn't been made with the Bloc to lock them in early because you couldn't put three people together in … three hours. The first part was done a long time ago. I won't go into details."

NDP deputy leader Thomas Mulcair said at a news conference that nothing in the NDP-BQ talks is any different than the contingency planning Stephen Harper himself engaged in with the two parties during the last Liberal minority in 2004.

He said the meeting, whose co-ordinates were inadvertently given to a Tory, were illegally recorded and broadcast and that the party has consulted two experts including a legal specialist for an opinion on whether the Criminal Code was violated.

The Conservatives intercepting a telephone call is caught neatly under s. 184(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada which reads:
184. (1) Every one who, by means of any electro-magnetic, acoustic, mechanical or other device, wilfully intercepts a private communication is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years.

This is the Harper Conservatives bugging their political opponents. And who knows how long they have been doing this for. This is criminal. This is Watergate-type. Clearly the high-level Conservatives knew about this, and authorized both the bugging and the release of the information. They knew about it, and by authorizing the release of the recording, they abetted the offence after the fact. If Harper knew about and authorized it, he is equally guilty and should go on trial.

Even if criminal proceedings are not commenced against the dirty-tricks types in the Conservative Party, the Speaker should find the whole load of them to be in contempt of Parliament. Bugging the meetings of members is pretty much the definition of breaching the Parliamentary privileges of MPs.

The Harper government is inept, dishonest, desperate, and now criminal. When the Conservatives admit to a crime to cling to power, it is over. THROW THE BUMS OUT! COALITION NOW!

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 51

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Harper Lies About the Constitution

Shame on Mr. Harper. Last night, at his specially constructed and pseudo-Presidential podium in the foyer of the House of Commons (does he really think he is too good to go to the Press Gallery as every PM before him has done?), Steveo lied to the people of Canada.

He got up on his hind legs and started spewing nonsense about how the opposition could not form a coalition and govern without an election. This is bullshit, and what is worse I'm sure he knows it.

The King-Byng affair, as well as numerous precedents in both the provincial legislatures and the British Parliament, affirms that the Queen or her representative has every right in a situation where the government loses the confidence of the House during the first sitting of the Parliament to ask an opposition party leader to try to assemble a government that can gain the confidence of the House. This is the whole point of our parliamentary system, and it is why the opposition is known as both "Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition" and the "government-in-waiting."

Steveo has unleashed his con-bots across the Internet, all screeching the same lines about a coalition government being anti-democratic and even anti-constitutional. This is part of a coordinated attempt to politically undermine the coming coalition government, but it is being done by lying to the people of Canada.

Part of the reason for the ferocity, and mendacity, of this response to the looming collapse of the government is surely fear. The Conservatives very likely cooked the books in the financial statement if not before, and they are deadly afraid of the opposition getting into the Ministry of Finance and finding the documents to prove it. The Conservatives have, in their three years in control of the government, surely lied and covered up multitudinous sins. Once the opposition gets in there, they are all coming out, and the Conservatives know that it will be doled out piecemeal, and they will be completely sunk in the next election. And so they are afraid.

And the result of that fear is the lies being spouted to the Canadian public by Conservatives from Steveo on down. This government lies to the public, and if for no other reason it thereby renders itself unfit to govern.

Update: The Con-bots now have their talking points for call-in shows. The CPC has a whole site set up for their partisans who are apparently either too stupid to think what to say for themselves or too untrustworthy to be allowed to come up with their own lines. You can find the CPC talking-points site here. I got their talking-points for the coalition negotiations (yes I was bad and put in a fake postal code), and here they are:

Opposition lacks mandate to take power

  • Is anyone else outraged by what the Opposition Parties are doing in Ottawa?
  • We’re not even two months removed from the last election, and a group of backroom politicians are going to pick who the Prime Minister is. Canadians didn’t vote for this person. We don’t even know who this person will be.
  • Not a single voter voted for a Liberal-NDP coalition. Certainly not a single voter voted for the Liberals to form a coalition with the separatists in the Bloc.
  • Add – what’s worse the Liberals even promised that there wouldn’t be a coalition with the NDP – this is all about power, all about money and they don’t even want to face the voters
  • This is what bothers me the most. The Conservatives won the election. The Opposition keeps saying that the Conservatives have to respect the will of the voters that this is a minority and so on. …how about Liberals, NDP and Bloc respecting the will of the voters when they said “YOU LOSE”.
  • And what’s this going to do to the economy. I’m sorry, I don’t care how desperate the Liberals are – giving socialists (Jack Layton) and separatists (Gilles Duceppe) a veto over every decision in government – that is a recipe for total economic disaster.
  • Here is what is bothering me about all of this backroom opposition coalition talk.
  • Sure it bothers me that parties Canadian rejected are trying to seize power through the back door.
  • But how more phony could these guys be? I mean, I follow the news, virtually every single day you have Harper or Flaherty out there telegraphing exactly what they plan to do with the economy. And not once did you hear the Liberals, NDP or separatists talking about toppling the government in response.
  • No – do you know what set this off. When Flaherty said he was going to take taxpayer-funded subsidies away from the opposition. Now there is a reason to try and overturn an election– because the Conservatives the audacity to say “Hey, it’s a recession, maybe you should take your nose out of the trough.”
  • And I wish the media would be more clear on this point – the opposition aren’t being singled out by this fact the Conservatives stand to lose the most money of all. The only difference is that Canadians are voluntarily giving money the Conservatives, so they don’t need taxpayer handouts. The only reason the opposition would be hurt more is because nobody wants to donate to them. They should be putting their efforts towards fixing that problem.
  • I don’t want another election. But what I want even less is a surprise backroom Prime Minister whom I never even had the opportunity to vote for or against. What an insult to democracy.
Not only is it stupid and inane, it is full of lies.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 52

Friday, November 28, 2008

Harper Scampers to Save His Government

Craven Stephen Harper, the true small-man of Confederation has pushed back the opposition day scheduled for Monday by a week in a desperate attempt to save his government that is suddenly on the rocks. Flim-Flam Flaherty's economic update included more poison pills than the opposition could ever have been rationally expected to swallow, including not only the elimination of public campaign financing, but also a frontal attack on collective bargaining rights and the equal rights of women.

Flaherty took union busting to the next level, declaring that the government would use the power of the Crown to roll back collective bargaining and arbitral gains on wage increases, and eliminate the right to strike over wages until 2010-11. Not only is this piece of legislation mean spirited in the extreme, it is quite possibly illegal in light of the Supreme Court decision made last year that overturned BC's Bill 29 which tried to do much the same thing. Workers have a right to the gains they have made, and they have the right to withhold labour over whatever they please.

The government has also made a frontal assault on the pay equity of women, by stating in the economic update that pay equity would not be retroactive, and the right to recourse to the Canadian Human Rights Commission would be removed. This is insane. In the years since the courts forced the government into pay equity, this is the biggest attempt to go back on what was ordered. I don't know where the government gets off trying to eliminate the rights of women retroactively.

This stuff is red meat right out of the reform party platforms of the mid-1990s. This is our "moderate" Prime Minister. The opposition parties were never going to accept this, and it was a red flag. This is our government's way of kicking their opponents when they are down, like a bully on the school yard. We are being governed by people who behave like maladjusted eight year olds.

Dipper Chick summed up my feelings about the coalition quite nicely:
A month or so ago, I never thought that there would be a set of circumstances that would make me supportive of the NDP forming a coalition with the Liberals. But here we are.

...

I am not feeling the slightest bit complacent about any of this. The Conservatives need to be stopped. I still don't trust the Liberals, and I still believe that an NDP government is what Canadians really need. But right here and now, with things being as they are, a Liberal-NDP coalition is the best option.

My apprehension comes from wondering if the Liberals can be fair while negotiating the terms of the coalition. I have a hard time believing that they can put their sense of entitlement aside and offer the NDP a significant enough role to form a true coalition. But if they can come to an agreement that is fair, I say take Harper down.
This coalition is necessary, but Stephen Harper will do everything he can to avoid it. He's going to take the week of grace he fabricated for himself and try to turn the Canadian people against his bully-boy government. I have faith that the Canadian people will see through the thing tissue of rationalizations, excuses and lies that Harper is putting forth.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 53

Coalition Government Looks Increasingly Likely

The news is breaking today that Jean Chretien and Ed Broadbent have been brokering the coalition talks between the Liberals and NDP. These two elder statesmen are working together to produce a workable coalition government that will be supported by the BQ.

Various opposition MPs have been sounding increasingly sure that the government will fall next week, including a statement by NDP Deputy Leader and Finance Critic Thomas Mulcair during question period today. If the Conservatives don't blink, they will get voted out of power by the House.

Even if the Conservatives do blink on the campaign financing, they may get voted out anyway, due to the failure to provide fiscal stimulus in the economic update. At this point, a coalition is entirely preferable to any Conservative government at all.

Days Remaining in Bush Presidency: 53